Barack Obama and Sarah Palin. Both are young, attractive and relatively inexperienced. Both engender a fervid dedication among devotees and bitter bile in their critics. And Sarah is catching up to him in the polls.
Jack Cashill, heroic slayer of liberal myths, has written a brilliant piece comparing and contrasting the trajectories of Sarah Palin and Barack Obama. No good soundbites, just a solid comparison that leaves the current president wanting while putting Palin in a very good light.
A Neutral View
Chris Good in an Atlantic article asks,
How Popular is Palin? It's standard boilerplate, but I liked this reader post, who offered a less flattering, but probably standard non-partisan comparison:
Jennis Psycho said:
She's about as popular as Obama, and slightly less divisive. Both are in the mid 40s in the reputable polls.
She's really just Obama's mirror image in a sense, both are largely ignorant and inexperienced politicians with penchants to say ridiculous and divisive things, and what you think about them largely says more about you than them.
Just like if Palin was ugly, if Obama wasn't an attractive African-American he would be Jimmy Carter, and about as popular.
That's bound to make Palinites mad, but they need to take a deep breath and realize that everyone doesn't share their devotion, and all criticism is not a hateful attack.
Kinda like W, I look to The Bible for a bit of political advice: Test the Spirits
Dear friends, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world.
-- 1 John 4:1
Palin has entered the arena, so she's fair game. And if she's as tough and sincere as she seems, she has nothing to worry about. I like my candidates tested in the crucible of political battle.
Rick Moran at Pajamas Media had the temerity to write an article critical of Palin, and her fans went nuts, calling this conservative all kinds of names!
Here is my comment:
OK Palinites, political hero worship is what has brought our country to the brink of disaster.
Sarah Palin is a fine woman and has a great record to stand on in Alaska politics. Like any politician in the public arena, she needs to be debated over and tested. It’s called the marketplace of ideas.
If you get testy because someone dares to question some aspect of her, you are no better than an Obamabot.
Lighten up! If Palin is the real deal she will withstand the criticism and prove a formidable candidate in 2012. If she can’t stand the heat, I’d rather find out now.
And screaming RINO! at everyone who disagrees with you is getting old. Scozzafava is a RINO. Rick Moran is a conservative who believes in “testing the spirits” by evaluating arguments and ideas.
If that’s not for you, stop trolling blogs where serious discussion takes place and instead spend your time at fan club sites where everybody agrees with you 100% of the time.
Let her speak
Although I have not made up my mind on this woman, I do get PO'd at the GOP Elitists. An Ivy League education is no substitute for common sense and strong values. Just ask the "best and brightest" who crashed our economy or who got us into Vietnam and then stabbed out troops in the back getting out.
This best sums up how I feel about the whole Sarah Palin phenomenon:
"Personally, I'm not sure she's ready to be president, but this is a person who has resonant voice for many Americans who are engaged in our political life and who deserve to have someone speaking for them," said Wilfred McClay, a professor at Pepperdine University's School of Public Policy.
"Anyone who tries to shut that down, particularly by a relentless campaign of personal abuse, is really an enemy of our political system," he said. "They are trying to suppress discourse at a time when we need more of it and not less." (Washington Times)
Time will tell...